In Nissan North America, Inc. v. Collins, IPR2012-00035, Paper 24 (January 22, 2013), the PTAB rebuked Nissan for an ex parte email that it send to a Judge asking to “know the proper procedure for requesting judicial notice of [a] false statement.” The email included substantive arguments regarding the patent owner’s preliminary response. In addition to admonishing Nissan, the PTAB allowed the patent owner the chance to responde to the email.
PRACTICE TIP: Do not make ex parte conctacts with the PTAB except to set up a conference call, and do not include substantive infomrtion or argument in such a request.